Most startup ideas fail one of four tests
Pain, timing, insight and reach: the four tests an idea must pass before it gets years of your life.
By Hassan Ed-dyb · · 2 min read
Short answer: before an idea gets years of your life, it should pass four tests. Pain: people already pay to solve the problem. Timing: something just changed. Insight: you see what others miss. Reach: you can name your first 100 users. Miss one and you will be pushing. Pass all four and the market pulls.
1. Pain: someone already pays
"Would you use this?" is the wrong question. Almost everyone says yes. The real signal is money already spent today on a worse solution: an agency, a spreadsheet, a person whose job is the workaround. If nobody pays for the problem now, they rarely start paying because your version is nicer.
2. Timing: something just changed
Good ideas are often old. What makes one possible now is a change: a new technology, a new rule, a new habit. Remote work became normal, and a company in Paris can now hire anyone, anywhere, in its own time zone. That shift is what opens the door, not the idea itself.
3. Insight: you see what others don't
An insight is a true thing most people haven't noticed yet. Morocco has world-class talent working in Europe's hours, fluent in French, Spanish and English, and it is still hard for companies to hire them directly. Once you see it, it seems obvious. That gap between obvious and acted on is where a company lives.
4. Reach: you can name your first 100 users
Not "small businesses" or "developers". Where are they, what do they read, who do they trust? If you can't answer, the best product in the world stays invisible. If you can, distribution starts on day one.
How to use the four tests
- —Write one sentence of evidence for each test. A feeling doesn't count; a fact does.
- —The test you can't fill is your riskiest assumption. Work on that one first.
- —Revisit them every few months. Timing and reach change faster than ideas.
Miss one and you push. Hit all four and the market pulls.